Over the last year, I have received not one, not two – but three toy helicopters as gifts! I’m a veritable helicopter magnet! Here then, a review of each of them.
I decided to test each of the helicopters on a course of my own devising, otherwise known as ‘I Am Maru book and cat ring toy’. Here’s a shot of the course:
The intention was to take off from I Am Maru, fly gracefully through the air, and land inside the ring toy. Helicopters would be rated therefore not only on fun, but also on control. This is important when you’re dealing with a helicopter!
Helicopter 1: Execuheli
The first copter I tested, a gift I’ve had for over a year, was the Execuheli. This helicopter is about 8 inches in length, has 2 rotors but no rear blade, and features LED lights both in the front and rear. The charger requires 6 AA batteries but the heli charges very quickly. It was manufactured in China.
The above shot shows the (wireless) controller. The stick on the left controls the rotor speed, and the stick on the right controls the orientation of the copter. Which means, in principle, you can control the flight of the bird by changing direction with the stick on the right. In reality… not so easy! But first, an action shot:
Yes my friends, there we have Execuheli in flight! You can see I had modified the course a bit, specifically by adding a tower of Star Wars tins, but this was a moot change since this helicopter was beyond my control! Oh I could get it flying easily enough, but where it went from there was entirely up to it! The right stick felt more like a binary toggle switch between ‘on the bleeding edge of control’ and ‘utterly out of control’ and tiny twiddles of it led instantly to spectacular crashes.
Verdict: Execuheli leaves the ground, but rarely made it back alive 🙂
Helicopter 2: Stinger
The next copter, a gift from my brother, was a marvel of miniaturization called Stinger.
This baby is tiny – only about 5 inches in length, and features 2 rotors, a rear rotor, flashing LED’s and gyroscopic control (although, to be honest, I’m sure they all feature that). It is spectacularly lightweight – it feels like nothing in your hand. And it’s very, very pretty. This little marvel was made in the PRC.
Stinger flies with slightly more control than Execuheli (perhaps due to the rear rotor?), and responds better to slight adjustements of the controller. Unlike the previous copter, I was actually able to keep this guy aloft for relatively long periods. Here’s a video of the action:
You can see the flight is smooth, stable and almost under my control. At least until it attacked me in the bollocks.
Verdict: A clever and fun little toy!
Helicopter 3: i-helicopter air
To the last of the three, one of my Christmas gifts, is the pompously named i-helicopter air.
You’ve probably seen these advertised: helicopters that are controlled by your i-device (iPhone, iPad, iPod). The copter itself is by far the largest of the three I own (probably over 10 inches in length), which means it is also the heaviest. Strangely it also has the least amount of tech – missing a rear rotor and only having one (non flashing) LED. It charges from a USB cable, and took by far the longest to charge as well. This helicopter was made in ??.
The above shot shows the i-helicopter air and the controller, which is to say KLS’s iPad. The helicopter itself came with the IR transmitter you can see plugged into the iPad, and the control software had to be downloaded (free) from the App Store. I’ll admit I was nervous, since the reviews are bad and many comments say the helicopter simply doesn’t work, or when it does the lag is so great that it’s uncontrollable. It was with some hesitation that I fired it up the first time.
But I was to be pleasantly surprised! Not only did it work, but the helicopter flew gracefully and with great stability. Granted the control was almost nonexistant (it doesn’t turn, for instance), but it was stable enough (unlike Execuheli) that it could just hover without moving quite well and look good doing it. Yes there is a control delay, and yes the lack of turning is an issue, but the stability of this helicopter was perhaps the greatest and it was the only one I successfully landed.
Verdict: Gimmicky control, but well built craft.
Overall, there is a clear winner here between the three, and that is unquestionably Stinger. It was the most fun, had the most flashing lights, and had the best control. It was also the smallest, which made the technology seem even cooler. These things are sold under zillions of names in gazillions of configurations, but I’ll conclude based on this test that at the very least you should look for tail rotors and lots of flashing LED’s if you’re in the market for a toy helicopter.
That said, I must be honest and admit that all of these toys contain a high level of frustration since ‘controlling’ them seems a crapshoot at best. This is true of all helicopters though, and faulting them for this is like faulting a fish for swimming. Helicopter toys are by their nature very difficult to control, and it’s a marvel that any of these (especially the tiny Stinger) do the job as well as they do.
I’m surprised you had the best luck with the Stinger. I’m certain it’s the cheapest of the lot.
I have a Stinger and, exactly as you found, trying to control it is an exercise in frustration.
I’m a little scared of it as well as it seems to have a mind of it’s own. It tends to always want to fly directly towards my face.
“Copped a feel.” Hehe. Took me a while.